The pellet durability index (PDI) is the percentage of pellets, by weight, that stay whole after a standard tumbling test. In the ASAE S269 tumbling-box method, 500 g of cooled, sieved pellets are tumbled in a 30 × 30 × 12 cm box at 50 rpm for 10 minutes, sieved again and weighed: PDI = weight of whole pellets after tumbling ÷ weight before × 100. PDI is the standard way to compare pellet binders such as lignosulfonate.
The Two Common PDI Methods
| Item | Tumbling box (ASAE S269) | Holmen tester |
|---|---|---|
| Sample | 500 g of cooled, sieved pellets | 100 g of sieved pellets |
| Stress | Box with a diagonal baffle, 50 rpm, 10 min | Pellets blown through a pneumatic circuit |
| Test time | About 10 min plus sieving | Short, typically under a minute |
| Comparability | Widely used reference in research | Gives lower values on weak pellets; not directly interchangeable with tumbling-box results |
| Modified versions | Hex nuts are sometimes added to increase stress for very durable pellets | Different run times are used for different feeds |
How to Run a Fair Binder Comparison
- Same formula, same mill, same day. Run the control (no binder) and each binder level back-to-back on the same die, conditioning temperature and throughput.
- Sample after cooling. Take pellets after the cooler, not at the die; hot pellets are softer.
- Sieve first. Remove fines with the sieve size specified for the pellet diameter before tumbling.
- Replicate. At least three samples per treatment; report the mean and spread.
- Record the process. Conditioning temperature, steam, moisture, die L/D ratio, production rate and energy use (kWh/t) all affect PDI as much as the binder.
- Measure fines in the real chain. PDI predicts fines at feeders; confirm with samples from bulk trucks or feeder lines where possible.
Example Trial Layout for a Lignosulfonate Binder
| Treatment | Binder inclusion (complete feed) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Control | 0 | Same formula without binder |
| Low | For example 0.5% | Below the EU maximum for all species |
| Mid | For example 0.75% | Within the 8,000 mg/kg EU limit for “other” species |
| High | For example 1.0% | Only for categories with a 10,000 mg/kg EU limit |
Feed-grade data sheets follow the EU limits: up to 0.8% of complete feed, or 1.0% for the five categories named in Regulation (EU) 2024/749. Liquid grades are dosed on a solids basis: a 45%-solids liquid at 1.5% of feed supplies about 0.68% dry lignosulfonate product. See calcium lignosulfonate feed grade and liquid lignosulfonate.
EU Legal Limits to Respect in Trials
| Species / category (EU, 1g565) | Maximum lignosulphonate, mg/kg complete feed (12% moisture) |
|---|---|
| Weaned piglets, pigs for fattening, chickens for fattening, laying hens, cattle for fattening | 10,000 (1.0%) |
| All other animal species and categories | 8,000 (0.8%) |
Interpreting PDI Results
- A higher PDI means fewer fines, but there is no universal target; set it with the customer and the feeding system.
- Compare against the control from the same run, not against historical values.
- If PDI rises but throughput falls or energy use rises, report all three; binder choice is a cost balance.
- Other factors – fat addition after pelleting, fibre, particle size, starch gelatinisation – can outweigh binder effects.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a good PDI for feed pellets?
There is no single standard. Targets are set by the feed type and handling chain. Compare treatments against a control from the same production run using the same PDI method.
Is the Holmen PDI the same as the tumbling-box PDI?
No. The two methods apply different stress and give different values, especially for weaker pellets. Report which method was used.
How much lignosulfonate is used in feed pellets?
In the EU the maximum is 8,000 mg/kg (0.8%) of complete feed for most species and 10,000 mg/kg (1.0%) for five named categories; feed-grade data sheets follow these limits. Trials usually test levels below the maximum.
References
- Kansas State University Research and Extension, Evaluating Pellet Quality (MF3228)
- Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/749, lignosulphonate as a feed additive (1g565)
Related Pages
- Calcium lignosulfonate, feed grade
- Sodium lignosulfonate, feed grade
- Lignosulfonate pellet binder selection guide
Questions about a specification, a test method or a trial: contact us or email info@greenagrochem.com.





